Hey, it’s Colleen. Hi, it’s Kate. And it’s Megan. And we’re the three scheme queens.
We’re using our medical background to focus on the strange, baffling, and downright unsettling world of medical mysteries.
We’re gonna dig into unusual cases, diagnostic puzzles, unexplained symptoms, and medical misadventures.
Our first three seasons covered a little bit of everything, including crime, conspiracy, mystery, and the occasional rabbit hole we probably shouldn’t have gone down.
Those episodes aren’t going anywhere, so the archives remain open for anyone who likes their mysteries, a little more broad spectrum.
But from season four on, the prescription is different. More medicine, more mysteries, more questions. So grab a drink, hit the follow, and tune in every Tuesday for a new episode.
Hi guys, welcome to a two scheme queen episode.
Yeah, it’s a little Halloween episode. Hopefully, you guys all enjoyed your Saturday Halloween.
I’m pro a rollover. Like I decorate for the holidays early, but I’m pro like continuing to the next week.
November 1st is not Christmas all of a sudden.
No, but it’s kind of like Christmas fall. Like I’ll start putting green things out with my orange things.
Interesting.
I don’t think you like go through a shock of putting everything away.
Okay. Sometimes you just throw a blanket on top of it, right?
Yeah. And we we don’t judge people who do that. I don’t.
It’s because you are the you are people. After this episode, we want you to pull out your phone. Who should they send it to, Colleen?
Three people that you may know from New England.
Okay. And then scroll on down, leave us a five-star review, and head on over to Instagram or our Patreon and chat with us. Let us know what you think.
Interact with us know what’s up. Give us some love. After you finish listening to this podcast, go check out Med Crimes, the podcast that takes you inside the disturbing intersection of medicine and true crime. If you love good medical mystery, a jaw-dropping crime story, or just finding out what happens when someone takes do no harm as more of a suggestion than a rule. This is the podcast for you. So check out Med Crimes wherever you get your podcasts and tell them the ladies of three Skin Queens sent you.
So is it time for our Dream Chat? Drink chat. You know, Kate’s not with us, so we’re taking advantage.
We’re drinking a breweriski.
We’re drinking a beer, not just any beer, a beer from New England. Boston. We’re drinking a Sam Adams Oktoberfest. Good choice, Colleen. Cheers. Never disappoints. Cheers.
And let’s get into it. Disclaimer: the views, opinions, and commentary expressed on this podcast are those of the hosts and guests and do not represent the view or opinions of our employers, organizations, or professional affiliations.
So speaking of New England, this week we’re traveling about 20 minutes from Colleen’s childhood home to Salem, Massachusetts.
Yeah, we used to go to Salem all the time. That’s where the beaches are or where the Salem willows are. I love the Salem Willows. There’s a campground. Oh, what is the campground called? Where there’s a beach, a public beach on it, too. And we used to go there all the time. Great seaglass.
Did we did I not take a ferry from Boston to Salem? Is that a possible? Yeah. That’s a possible that would make sense.
Yeah. That’s actually a big commuter route.
I went to Salem for Halloween a couple years ago. Ooh. Um, and it was a great time.
Now, see, I don’t think it’s worth it to go on Halloween because it’s just that crazy.
It wasn’t a lot, but you know what? It wasn’t as bad. I feel like I don’t usually like large crowds, but I don’t remember feeling like claustrophobic. But it was interesting. I saw a lot of the sites that I read about when I researched this podcast episode. So we are talking about the Salem Witch Trials. Spooky. In 1692, a group of young girls in colonial Massachusetts began experiencing bizarre symptoms, including violent convulsions, uncontrollable screaming, strange movements, and claims that invisible forces were attacking them. With no clear medical explanation, their community concluded that witchcraft was responsible. Over the next year and a half, more than 200 people were accused of witchcraft with a total of 25 people dying. But more than 300 years later, researchers have proposed several alternative explanations, including mass psychogenic illness, air got poisoning, neurological disorders, and psychological trauma. In honor of Halloween, let’s go back to Salem and meet the patients, examine the differential diagnosis, explore the historical evidence, and ultimately ask whether modern medicine could have prevented the tragedy. Wow. Did you guys learn a lot about the Salem witch trials growing up? In school, no.
I don’t think I’ve ever had like a lesson on the Salem Witch trial. It was just like what you knew. And then there was like movies and stuff like that.
And then I’ve just been to Salem and I’ve done the the tours, the museum, the burial ground, the hanging spot.
Oh yeah. It’s it’s like all walkable.
Yeah. The hanging spot is like in in someone’s backyard. It’s very weird. Very weird.
Salem is very quaint, like it’s very cutesy. Um, and everything’s on top of each other.
But you guys didn’t learn about the Puritans, right?
Oh yeah. I mean the pilgrims.
Are the pilgrims of the Puritans the same?
Yeah. But I never grew up calling them Puritans. I always called them the pilgrims.
So I’m gonna fact check you there, Colleen. Oh god. Pilgrims were separatists who completely broke away from the church. Puritans were reformers who wanted to fix and purify the church from within. And I think Puritans were very regimented, structured, religious, their whole day revolved around God, their religion. Anything that happened was like a reflection of God or the devil. Well, in the medieval times, the church believed that the devil could gift people with the power to harm others in exchange for loyalty. And from the 1300s to 1600s, tens of thousands of women were executed in Europe as part of the European witch trials. But they sort of had started to calm down by the 1600s. So this was not like in the grand scheme of witch trials.
The Salem witch trials are I don’t think I knew that there was a European witch trial on a much larger scale. So this is really one not that many died.
25 people.
Okay.
Well, like except a lot. What if you were one of the 25? I mean, it did kind of make me angry at the at the children, but we’ll talk about it. I’m glad you’re already learning things, Colleen. In 1689, King William’s war ravaged upstate New York and what is now Canada, sending refugees to flee to Salem Village in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. So we have Salem Village, that’s what’s now known as Danvers, Massachusetts. It was sort of a a more like I don’t know, impoverished area, but more sort of like agricultural and that sort of thing. And then we had the Salem Colony, which is now Salem. That was more affluent, kind of people had more money there. So there was a bit of a rivalry between these two colonies, and there was a strain on resources because we already have these kind of two colonies, and then we have all these people coming down from the north. So resources are strained. It wasn’t a great crop year. And then they also had tension with the Native Americans. In 1689, Samuel Paris became the village’s ordained minister, and he had a reputation for being particularly rigid and greedy. He was, he didn’t really have this like calling to the church until later in life. He was sort of a failed businessman down like the Caribbean and then up in Boston. And then he decided to become a minister and he did like fire and brimstone sermons eight hours a day, six days a week. You got one day off, and then he’d go home and he would, you know, practice his prayer within his own home. That was sort of the surrounding situation leading up to this. So let’s go back to where this all started. We have nine-year-old Betty Paris. She’s the yes, Elizabeth, but Betty.
Hold up. I was right.
Uh, she’s the daughter of Minister Samuel Paris, I just told you about. And then her cousin, 11-year-old Abigail Williams, lives with them. She’s like an orphan from this war, and she’s so she’s like a servant in the Paris, Paris household.
I think you can go to this house.
You can. Yeah. But it’s really this is just like the remnant. This is um, this is not the big black house, it’s a museum now. Oh, this this is no, this is like there’s some stones. There’s not much to see.
I like going to see stones. When I went to Scotland, that’s all I wanted to see.
What gets told in a lot of the documentaries is that they were really into doing some kind of like sort of some mystical thing. Spiritual, which was really frowned upon in the Puritan community. Okay. So this was like very hush-hush. So one of the things they would do is they would put an egg white in a cup of water and watch how the egg whites settled, and that would give them clues about their future husband, like what he would do for work or that kind of thing.
Oh, yeah.
So they were doing, they’re playing this game, the two cousins, and I guess the egg white kind of settled to the shape of a coffin and they got really freaked out. Like, what does that mean? Is our husband dead? Is he gonna die? What’s going on? The one of the rumors is they didn’t actually get caught doing that, but did they have like a lot of anxiety and panic and fear because they were doing this thing that they knew they weren’t supposed to do? They got this really creepy, what they interpreted as like this this creepy response. And is that sort of where all of this started? So then they began experiencing fits of sudden screaming and crying, convulsions, unusual contortions or movements. They would hide or crawl beneath furniture, and they would complain of being punched or attacked by invisible entities, and they would have episodes of distress without an identifiable physical cause. So Samuel Paris calls the local physician, William Griggs, and he comes in to assess the girls, and he cannot find a cause for these symptoms, and he says that he thinks they are bewitched. Oh witch. So also in the house is tichuba. Tichuba was a slave that Samuel Paris had brought with him from Barbados. Cause remember, I told you that he used to like run a plantation down there that kind of fell apart, came to ruin. So he comes up to Massachusetts and he brings Tichuba with him. And she, under the encouragement of a neighbor, tried to use a folk remedy in which she bakes the girl’s urine into some bread. No, then feeds the bread to a dog, and it’s supposed to break the curse. The dog eating the bread is supposed to break this connection to the witch or whatever, right? So she is doing this at the encouragement of a neighbor because she’s trying to be helpful, right? So she gets caught and she’s punished, okay? In the meantime, yes, because she’s she’s practicing her own witchcraft, right? There’s like a fine line here. This all happens, and then he continues to question the girls, Betty and Abigail, like who is torturing you? Who is, you know, what’s going on? What’s going on? And finally, they say, you know, Tichuba was already in trouble, right? She’s in the house. They say it was Tichiba. And he’s like, Who else was it? Who else was it? And the girls end up pointing their fingers at two other people. So Sarah Good, who was a homeless beggar, and Sarah Osborne, who was an elderly impoverished woman who was sort of on the outs in general. She there was like she was like having a fling with a guy who worked for her, and uh, she was like already not really well respected in the community. So these first three people who were accused are sort of like the dregs on the edge of society, right? Right. They’re called before Jonathan Hathorne and Jonathan Corwin, who are two local businessmen who are acting as magistrates. So they bring Sarah Good up and they say, Sarah Good, are you a witch? And Sarah says, I am not a witch, but Sarah Osborne is a witch. So everyone’s just pointing fingers. So then Sarah Osborne gets pulled up and she’s like, I am not a witch. If anything, I am being haunted by witches. I am being tortured by apparitions. The third person it questioned is Tichuba. And Titsuba’s like, that didn’t, this questioning did not go so well for these two girls. So I gotta do something different, right? So she decides to confess, presumably to appease the court. And she says, Yes, there was a tall man in a black hat, which historians now believe that she was describing Paris. She said, The devil came to me and bid me serve him. She said she refused, and he returned to her, and she saw apparitions of birds and animals with faces of Sarah Good and Sarah Osborne, and that the devil wanted her to sign his book. So she said, Eventually, I did sign the book, but when I signed the book, there were nine other names before mine. And then she goes blind and mute, and the interrogation ends. So now they’re convinced there are nine witches who have sold their soul to the devil and they need to figure out who these witches are. Okay. That’s crazy. Over the next month, other young girls in the community begin to exhibit similar symptoms, including Mercy Lewis, Elizabeth Hubbard, and Mary Wolcott. And these are young girls, they’re all under the age of 18, but they’re starting to get a little bit older, right? The first girl was nine and eleven. Now we have like 18-year-old girls. And they had also all sort of been orphaned or marginalized by the community. A lot of them, they were working as like, again, servants in the houses of family members. Again, we don’t really have like affluent people here who are pointing their fingers or who are blaming people who are being blamed. It’s like the people doing the blaming are sort of again the edge of society. And then the people who are being blamed are sort of on the edge of society. So they do they start putting their fingers over time with people who are less of like the stereotype and more of like contributing members to society. And it gets really sad because when they get accused, they get questioned in front of the magistrate, and they all get sent to jail in Boston. Girl gang in jail. It was a girl gang in jail, but they would get sent to jail. They would be tortured in hopes of getting a confession out of them.
Right.
They have to pay room and board. Oh, so they are paying to be like, you know, left in chains.
Well, if you can’t afford it.
Then you don’t get to leave jail. Once you’re like acquitted, if you get acquitted, you can’t leave until your debts are paid. Oh my God. And you don’t get any food or clothing that isn’t brought to you. So you have to have someone on the outside who like is still supporting you. Oh my God. That’s awful. Mary Warren was one of the girls who was afflicted with the early group. She, I think, had maybe some regrets and claimed to be cured. The other girls then accused her of being a witch. So then she sort of had to flip sides and she ended up in jail as well. And when they came to question her, she kind of freaked her story and agreed to testify against the alleged witches. She was like, No, I I am unafflicted. Anyway, a lot of flip-flopping. But the point is, months are going on, everyone is getting accused. Okay.
Yes.
By May of this year, so we’re five months into this, a special court was established to hear witchcraft cases. Bridget Bishop was the first accused witch brought in front of the special court who claimed innocence, but she was found guilty, and she became the first person hanged on what became known as Gallows Hill, then there. I would say the majority of people seem to be behind this because, again, I think just the time everything was like explained by religion and the devil. And so most of the people were believing these young girls, but there were people who were like, this is sort of getting out of control. So respected minister Cotton Mather and his father, who was Harvard president, Increase Mather, they both wrote letters pleading with the court not to allow spectral evidence, which is dreams or visions. So anyone can get up and say, I had a vision that she pushed me, right? There’s no proof proof.
Yeah.
So they’re like, How can you be using that as evidence in the court of law? There is no innocent until proven guilty in this situation. There’s no real rules about the evidence that’s being introduced. And so some of these people are like, This is this is not right. We’re getting out of control here.
You can’t operate like that.
The request was ignored, and over the next several months, 19 people were hanged, starting with Bridget Bishop on June 2nd, 1692. One man, Giles Corey, his wife was also accused, was pressed to death because he refused to enter a plea. So they pressed him to death with heavy stones. If Kate were here, she’d be so upset. Even dogs were killed because locals believed they were linked to the devil.
And the cats, though. I thought the cats too.
Okay. I just I just read about dogs, but maybe cats. Nobody ever cares about cats, Benny. So again, you asked about like the like how could they be found not guilty? What was the evidence? So witnesses claim to see spirits or apparitions of accused individuals attacking them, with witnesses often experiencing dramatic symptoms during courtroom proceedings. So this was all part of it too, right? Is that when they’re questioning these people, they’re all in there together and they’re feeding off each other. And the whole time I’m like reading about this and watching these documentaries, I’m like, why didn’t they just separate all the girls? They never just like separated them and made sure that there was like consistent experiences. They were always together. And so then, like, one of them would start acting out, they’d all act out, right? So it kind of like fed, it was like a positive feedback in these court proceedings. This is hysteria. Some accused individuals were physically examined for unusual skin findings, thought to indicate a connection with the devil. So if you had things like moles, birthmarks, skin tags, or scars, they would say this is a sign that you’re kicked to the devil, and this is more proof that you are guilty. Guys, I’m fucked.
I got all of those.
They also used the touch test, which was a belief that held that touching a witch might relieve an afflicted person’s symptoms. So again, just being in the courtroom, having all these people there who were acting out, sort of created this like feedback loop in which symptoms reinforce the accusations, and then the accusations reinforce the symptoms. And there you go. As the allegations snowballed, Governor William Phipps’ wife was accused, which led him. So now the governor’s like, this is too much, and we’re done. We’re not arresting any more people, and we’re gonna start releasing the accused witches.
Not my girl.
Yeah, that was the line. He dissolved the special courts, replacing them with superior court that did not allow spectral evidence. So at that, once they switched over and they said, Okay, no more like visions or dreams being used as evidence. Only three out of 56 defendants were found guilty.
Because I want there to actually have been witches, but I don’t know if there was.
I’m gonna say no.
At least I’m gonna choose there were.
Okay, okay. Well, we’ll get to that. On January 14th, 1697, Massachusetts General Court ordered a day of fasting and soul searching. And in 1702, the trials were declared unlawful. I thought, isn’t that sort of how like Thanksgiving started? Was these like court-ordered days of reflection? I guess we had feet it’s feasting, not fasting, though.
Yeah. I thought Thanksgiving came to be because the Native Americans helped us.
Yeah, but it wasn’t the story we were all told. We talked about that in uh Old Wives episode. We did a whole episode on the truth about Thanksgiving. And it is not the story of they we all sat down together for a happy meal.
No, but like they did help.
So in reality, the Wampanoag tribe approached the colonists after four months of careful and quiet observation, and the approach was a political strategy as the indigenous people had had negative interactions with previous settlers, i.e., Pocahontas. They proposed an alliance, the colonists would help them fight another tribe that they were in opposition with, and in and allow them access to trade. In return, the pilgrims would have access to resources. Apparently, the pilgrims were doing a celebration of the harvest as they had unofficially been doing for centuries. So in general, it was sort of like a religious these like days of like prayer and fasting, and then sometimes followed by feasting, was sort of routinely done before a harvest or and after a harvest. So this was sort of like a multi-times a year this sort of thing happened. Right. It wasn’t just no, and so the pilgrims were having the celebration, and accounts suggest that the Wampanoag arrived after hearing gunshots from a harvest celebration and came to investigate, initially fearing an attack. So they roll up thinking there’s a fight happening, and then they’re like, oh wait, it’s a party. Hold up. There’s also stories that uh one of the leaders had been making diplomatic calls at this time. But again, they did sit down and have this meal. It was mostly actually the food was mostly brought by the Wampanoag people. They brought I knew, yeah. They brought deer. Uh not even turkey or some other type of cooked fowl, but they think it was most likely duck, not turkey. Crazy. The original feast in 1621 occurred sometime between September 21st and November 11th. So it was like a one off sort of thing. Like I said, they sort of did these every now and then, but there was no annual tradition, like every year we’re gonna get together, we’re gonna celebrate. Okay. That we work together, right? New Englanders began celebrating kind of more consistently, nearly a century. Later. And again, it was this religious custom of spending days fasting, feasting, and praying as a way to give thanks. What were they all? They were Quakers. Pilgrims, Puritans, and Quakers were three different kinds of people. Okay. That’s what I thought. So the governor would like randomly pick these days and say, Be thankful. I’m declaring Thanksgiving. And then the New Englanders would celebrate. And there were a couple like random national Thanksgiving days where people would just say, Today is a national Thanksgiving day. In fact, George Washington declared one in 1789.
But they weren’t like it wasn’t the Thanksgiving we know today. Exactly.
It did not become an annual tradition until the 1800s when Sarah Josepha Hale, author of Mary Had a Little Lamb. Yep. She was a Mary Had a Little Lamb is that old? Whoa. Oh, this is a fun fact I found for you. So she was an author, but her husband died. Her husband was a Freemason. Husband died. She becomes this author. And the way she got published is because the Freemasons financed her. Suspicious. Maybe Mary Had a Little Lamb has another meaning. Oh. She served as the editor of Ladies’ Magazine from 1828 to 1836, and she was the first female editor ever. During that time, she spent decades writing hundreds of letters to politicians, ministers, newspapers, and five presidents advocating that the last Thursday in November be set aside to quote, offer to God our tribute of joy and gratitude for the blessings of the year. End quote. So in September of 1863, she wrote an editorial, she sent a letter to Abraham Lincoln advocating for a shared North and South holiday to encourage unity. On October 3rd, 1863, President Abraham Lincoln issued this Thanksgiving Day proclamation, and the goal was to unite this like war-divided country. He was not the first president to issue a Thanksgiving proclamation, but because of Abraham Lincoln, we have this national holiday. Annual tradition.
Okay.
Okay. In 1702, the trials were declared unlawful. In 1711, the colony passed a bill restoring rights and good names to many of the accused and granting a total of 600 pounds and restitution to their heirs. And then it sounds though like it really wasn’t until the late 1900s, like there were some people who were not included in this like pardon. And it wasn’t like the late, yeah, like like 1990s. I think some school, you might not some some like eighth grade civics class in New England, like rallied to get someone’s the last witch’s name cleared, last alleged witch’s name cleared, and a cleared her name. So this really, yeah, really went on until 30 years ago or so. That’s crazy. So that is kind of the summary of the Salem witch trials. But again, what we’re gonna talk about today is what caused the medicine. What happened in 1692? You have two young girls with unexplained convulsions, screaming episodes, and complaints of invisible attacks. Nowadays probably do a toxicology screen, an MRI, a lumbar puncture, EEG. I mean, but do the whole works and then get a psych consult. But we didn’t have any of those those tools back then. So in Salem instead, the answer was witchcraft. But there’s a couple of diagnoses that have kind of been been narrowed down, and no one really has like a strong answer for what happened here, okay?
Well, because it’s also like they only really documented what they wanted to document, right? Like, so it’s all like what the men said.
Exactly. This is there’s a lot of similarities to that first episode we did about the the mass hysteria, the dancing, the dancing plague. But I think like you said, you made a good point in that episode too, that like this isn’t quite as far back as that, but we’re relying on like 350-year-old records. And there’s a lot of there’s a lot of missing records, right? Like we don’t have a lot of information, and everything is that we do have is sort of clouded by this mentality that everything is related to the church, right? Everything is like a reward or a punishment from God or the devil, or so like what little documentation we do have, I think is not even just like the straight facts, right?
It’s like a third party retelling it how they thought it was.
Yeah. I mean, we have like the there’s all the documentation from the the hearings and that kind of thing, but yes, it’s still just sort of like the observational. So, what do you think the most common diagnosis that people use is here to explain this? Like the mass hysteria again. Yep, mass psychogenic illness.
Physically, what was really wrong with any of them? Did they any of them have any common symptom other than like the visions?
Um No, yeah, and you bring up a great point when we talk about infectious etiology, there’s nothing that really matched with that kind of picture. So the leading explanation, the leading hypothesis is that this was a mass psychogenic illness, which again occurs when multiple individuals within a connected community develop similar physical symptoms without an identifiable shared toxic, infectious, or neurologic cause. Again, when we think about mass psychogenic illness, a lot of times this can be like fainting, dizziness, tremors, abnormal movements, seizure-like episodes. I think we’re kind of getting into there’s sort of two diagnoses. There’s mass psychogenic illness, and then there’s functional neurologic disorder. The functional neurologic disorder is that exact condition in which you have genuine symptoms that don’t have a physical cause. And then when that sort of spreads in in a group, that’s when we call it mass psychogenic illness, right? Okay. So functional neurologic disorder. This is what they used to call conversion disorder, but we don’t call it that anymore. Again, different from like malingering when you’re faking it, conversion disorder is like these are real symptoms, but they’re caused by something psychological. These symptoms, again, are seizures, paralysis, tremors, abnormal movements, difficulty walking, loss of sensations, speech disturbances, and visual changes. And they typically occur, as we mentioned in the previous episode, in environments that have high stress, fear, uncertainty, or strong social connections. And that’s sort of what I told you we had at the beginning here that this was like a very, I think there was 550 people in the one community and about 900,000 in the other. These are close-knit communities. And again, we have a lot of stressors with uh multiple enemies and disease and poor crops, and so kind of a prime setting for something like this to happen.
Girl on girl crime. Uh, who are the most common people accusing? Men accusing women, women accusing women, young girls accusing women. Young girls accusing women.
Well, it started with a 9, 11-year-old, and then they got up to the teenagers. Um, and then it so it was like this it was sort of young women. The youngest person they accused was four and a half years old. Oh, she got sent to jail. They had to make special, special handcuffs, chains for her. Oh my god. Yep. So historically, outbreaks of unexplained neurologic symptoms are attributed to supernatural forces, environmental poisoning, or mysterious diseases. But again, now that we have modern medicine, there’s more of an appreciation for this the possibility of a mass psychogenic illness. We recognize that as a potential etiology, and we realize that there’s more that like social influences, expectations, sort of stressors can all play a role in um these like physical manifestations, right?
Because we’ve talked about it a few times. Do we have any like more recent mass hysteria examples?
Let me give you two modern day examples. Would I know them? Actually, you might know one of these because you spend more time on TikTok than me. Okay. I’m interested. Let’s go back to 2011 first. In LaRoy, New York, a group of teenagers developed sudden involuntary movements, facial ticks, and speech disturbances. Initially prompting concerns about what would you think would cause that? A bunch of teenagers all at once get this. Maybe some kind of toxic exposure, an environmental toxic.
Well, I’m thinking like they all smoked a little weed and something was in there. Okay. Um, teenagers. Teenagers having random movement problems.
There were also theories it could be something infectious, like maybe like a post-infectious syndrome. Maybe they all got strep. But then what was the age frame? They were all teenagers. Mono? But mono doesn’t usually cause all the like you’re thinking about something that’s easily.
But if you have mono and then you get meningitis or something.
Goes back also to our first episode when we talked about the dancing plague, that it is possible to have these like hyperinflammatory responses after an infection where like your brain gets attacked. We’re gonna touch on that again at the end, too. But the the idea that like 11 people would get an infection, and then all I just made up that number, but like that a large group of people would get an infection, and then that a large group would all have this rare complication is odd, right? So investigators were able to rule out any of these common physical causes, and they decided that this was probably a mass psychogenic illness involving functional neurological symptoms. And they determined that this was related to too much social media time. Oh and they limited the teenager’s social media exposure and all of their symptoms went away.
Well, good God, how much exposure were they getting?
Well, similarly, during COVID-19, neurologists reported a sharp increase in adolescence, predominantly teenage girls presenting with sudden onset, severe tick-like behaviors that differed from typical Tourette syndrome. Research has suggested that pandemic-related stress, social isolation, and exposure to tick-related content on social media may have contributed to the development and spread of functional symptoms. Uh, you’ve heard of this?
No, so I didn’t know it was a thing. It’s so funny that you’re telling me this because I thought it was weird how many people had Tourette’s online.
Interestingly, both the TikTok tick phenomenon and the Salem witch trials occurred during periods of widespread infectious disease, social disruption, isolation, and heightened anxiety. And while teenagers today were connected through social media, and that’s what they were seeing, at the time the girls of Salem lived in these small, tightly connected communities where they frequently interacted and witnessed one another’s symptoms. So, was this sort of just like the pre-internet version of this tick-tock tick phenomenon, right? That’s interesting. Now, the problem with the mass psychogenic illness diagnosis and the functional neurological disorder is that they both are sort of, we need additional, the diagnoses are made based on physical exam and diagnostic imaging, which we don’t have either of those. We don’t have a good physical exam and we don’t have any diagnostic imaging. And these are sort of diagnoses of exclusion. So we really can’t say, we cannot say for sure that this is FND or mass psychogenic illness. The other proposed etiology is air got poisoning. We talked about this also in that episode. The wheat, the fungus.
Oh, yes, okay.
And I do want to talk about this because I did a deeper dive into this. And at the time, I was pretty anti-air got poisoning for the dancing one because I couldn’t really separate these, like the gate, they didn’t, they had some of the symptoms, but not all of them, right? They didn’t have the gangrene, they didn’t have the basoconstriction that you know of. But I’ve done a deeper dive. And they did and I might have changed my mind. Air got poisoning again is when the the rye uh gets this fungus and it gets consumed, right? It creates this sort of LSD-like reaction. The chemical is sort of LSD-like. So you get a very similar LSD picture. Paranoia, hallucinations, twitches, and spasms, right? That’s erg ergotismus conv convulsivus. There’s also ergotismus gangrinosis. And so I thought you had to have, I thought both of these were the same kind of strand. And so with the gangrinosis, you get loss of peripheral sensation, you get swelling, that’s when the you’re you’re you get like the burning feet, and then they get gangrenous and they fall off. And I said the people who were dancing weren’t losing their feet, so I don’t think they could have this. But actually, you can have one type without the other. So the fungus, clavis claviceps purpurea, is not uniform. So you get different types of strain and they produce sort of different chemical cocktails. So a purely convulsive outbreak is driven by a strain that produces highly neurotropic alkaloids. So they act as potent serotonin receptor agonists in the central nervous system. They don’t have the basocotrictive alkaloids like ergotamine that shut down blood flow in the limbs. So it is possible to have just the convulsive form without the gangrenous form. So this makes us sort of more of a viable option to me.
Interesting.
Historically, communities consumed a diet heavily reliant on rye, but lacking vitamin A and essential fatty acids. And so a severe lack of vitamin A dramatically lowers the body’s threshold for neurologic damage, allowing convulsive symptoms and central nervous system overstimulation to take over before any vascular damage can occur. And we know this is usually contracted through a shared food supply, like a specific batch of contaminated rye flour. Conditions for the development of ergot poisoning were in place in 1691. There was it was a severe winter and a damp spring, which would have affected the rye consumed in early 1692. It was the young who were mostly afflicted. And they thought maybe these people have weaker immune systems. In general, the poison itself would wear off in a few weeks as long as you aren’t exposed again. So if you keep eating the same rye, it’s going to be a cycle. But if you just like eat it once within weeks, the results will or the all the symptoms will resolve and you’ll be fine. But the goal is to not die from like status epilepticus or asphyxiation or trauma in the meantime, right? Supportive care. So this all sounds promising, right? Yeah, actually. Okay. You’re on you’re on board. Well, the problem though is that there should have been more people within the same households afflicted. But it wasn’t like everyone in the house got this, right? There’s one or two people.
They’re probably not eating the same bread as the homeowner.
There were daughters of well-to-do people who were also accusers. Okay, I’ll give you that. Never mind. Dr. Griggs, who’s the one who said they’re bewitched, right? People are like, air got poisoning was sort of a known condition because we’d had all these previous outbreaks in Europe, including St. Anthony’s Fire, which we talked about. And so sort of considered general medical knowledge, but I don’t know about general medical knowledge because we hear about crazy things all the time that they believed and did, right?
This is also like Salem in the 1600s. Were they really up to date with what was going on with Europe right now?
Well, they were going back and forth. Yeah, I don’t know. Also, he could read, I guess, but he couldn’t write. And I’m just thinking about a doctor who who can’t write. I don’t know. Maybe it’s like when you can like understand Spanish but can’t really speak it, you know? When you can like get every couple words. I don’t know. But I’m just thinking, like, was this guy all that smart? Smart? And again, people were doing crazy in like the 1900s when they were just like giving opioid to opioids to everybody. So, like, you know, we have no direct evidence of contaminated rye and Salem. The recorded symptoms do not establish a consistent ergotism syndrome. The pattern of accusations and symptoms is difficult to explain through a single food or uh a single foodborne exposure. Subsequent scholars have looked back and they have kind of challenged this theory. So I kind of feel like I feel like I do not believe that as the source of the Salem Witch trials, but now that I’m understanding that you can have a separate, a separate, you know, convulsive form and a gangrenous form, I’d like to go back and change my opinion on episode one of season four and say maybe, maybe I’m on board with Colleen and Kate, and that’s what was happening with the dancing plague. They’re crazy. They’re all witches. The last potential diagnosis that has been floated is is it’s like a neurologic or infectious disease. So one medical theory proposed is that this could have been caused by encephalitis, which is inflammation of the brain tissue that can result from infections, such as a virus, or it can be an autoimmune response in which the body’s immune system mistakenly attacks the brain. And then depending on the underlying cause, the patient may develop headaches, fever, seizures, ultrametal status, hallucinations, personality changes, memory impairment, and abnormal movements. The problem with this in Salem is that encephalitis generally follows a pretty recognizable clinical course. Like patients usually just become progressively worse and worse and worse. They usually have fevers, confusion, decreased consciousness, uh life-threatening complications. They’re not walking, like they’re not moving. No, they’re not like I’m normal, and then all of a sudden I have this spell, and now I’m back to normal again. It’s much more of like this decline, right? So it doesn’t really, the description of what happened doesn’t really go along with that. Also, the resolution of it doesn’t track. Like if we’re thinking about some of the common like potential infectious etiologies, usually like HSV encephalitis, that’s one uh that we see a lot of that historically carried a mortality rate of 70%. And those patients often had severe neurologic impairment. So again, these girls didn’t seem to have any sort of not one per accuser died. Okay. Not one of these afflicted ever like died. So we have no evidence of like some kind of chronic, you know, medical condition. They also, as you pointed out, they didn’t have any, if this is like an infectious or a post-inflammatory encephalitis, you would think they would have had some sort of systemic symptom like a fever, yeah, a cough. And there was no kind of standard symptom like that. And then again, the more intriguing possibility, what I really like is autoimmune encephalitis. I always like that. Anti-NMD encephalitis for these patients that start, they initially look kind of like they’re having like a nuance at psychiatric symptoms that and maybe they get hallucinations, agitation, bizarre behavior, behavior personality changes. And then these are patients that used to sort of be misdiagnosed and sent to psychiatric ward, and then they would die, they develop seizures and die. And now we know that this is something we check for, but it’s very rare and it’s not contagious. So the idea that you would have all these people, you do like uh IVAG, plasma exchange, steroids, you have to look for it. Usually there’s a teratoma, so you have to look for a teratoma, remove the teratoma, and then it’s like shutting down the immune system. Again, the idea that you’d have all these people together who get this, this is again, this is like incredibly rare. And you’re not gonna have you’re not gonna have 200 people out of your community of under 2,000, you know. I think this was on Grayson Atomy. Might have been. Uh have you seen one? Many. Actually, seen many. Well, then how rare is it? Well, but I mean, many in the sense that we were where everyone got sent to. Oh they had it. I also think it was until the 90s not really diagnosed. The girl, the brain on fire. That’s what this girl has in brain on fire. Oh, and she sees all these people and nobody can figure out what’s wrong with her. That was a tricky story. It’s a good movie, actually. It’s a good book. Uh uh, or it could have been, I said, like ADM is usually what like kids get, which is acute disseminated encephalomyelitis. And it usually again happens autoimmune, inflammatory usually follows like some sort of infection. But again, we have no prodrome here that indicates these people were sick. So I think the lack of sustained ultra mental status, the fact that they don’t really meet the modern diagnostic criteria for encephalitis, which would be like ultramental status more than 24 hours, evidence of neurologic inflammation, whether that’s an MRI or lumbar puncture. We don’t have any of that, right? So we can’t really say it’s this. And again, we have no evidence of a recognizable stomach illness. And also it’s rare. Yeah, and these patients had all had favorable outcomes. Encephalitis patients don’t usually all just have 100% recovery. They didn’t get any kind of treatment beyond like fasting and prayer. God. And again, the weird the way it was transmitted, like a lot of these are not, should not just be transmitted from person to person. I mean, again, it could be something like encephalitis lethargica, which we talked about before we did our rebrand, where it was all these people got got a virus and they all had a complication. But again, we have no prodrome. So sorry, I do have one more. The one the last idea is like, were these just a bunch of brats who were just making the whole thing up? Yes. That’s that’s where you’re going.
I think either hysteria or that.
There is documented testimony suggesting that some of the girls knowingly fabricated accusations.
Maybe not all of them.
Yeah, I think more likely it’s some sort of combination. Yeah. Actually, what I think also. So we know that some of these people faked it. So Mary Warren reportedly, I said she admitted that they were faking it, and then she was accused of witchcraft, and then she had to recant and say, No, I am afflicted. And she had to testify against the other people. There was another afflicted girl who claimed to see the spirit of Elizabeth Proctor before admitting that she had done it for entertainment. So she was like, No, I made that story up. I lied. The Putnam family, particularly Thomas Putnam, had long-standing disputes involving property, community influence, and religious leadership. And his daughter, Ann Putnam Jr., became one of the most prolific accusers. So people are like, was she just accusing anyone who had like issues with her dad? Right. Probably. Or like, were these kids, not that their parents were like, go, you know, point your finger at that person, but maybe they’re at home and they’re hearing them talk about it, right? And I think too, it’s sort of like these women at the time were supposed to be silent. They’re supposed to just like pray and work. And they weren’t allowed to like speak unless spoken to, and they really had no rights. But now these girls have no control of themselves. So they’re running around and playing, they get to sass adults, they’re giving like, you know, mouth to the to the minister while he’s doing his sermons. And so they had some freedom. So maybe they enjoyed that as well. And the power, these women who never had any power now have the power to point a finger at you and send you to jail.
Yeah, it’s an epidemic of of brattiness and hysteria.
But again, deliberate deception doesn’t necessarily explain how the whole ordeal began. Did like the first girls develop unusual neurologic symptoms? Maybe the first two girls had uh ergot syndrome or something, right? Maybe the first two girls were panicked about the fact that they were reading their future and having anxiety, and they were in this sort of pseudo-abusive household where all they did was pray all day. And so maybe these like were true neurological symptoms they had they developed, and then it caught it sort of just spread. They say that like Paris, there was word he might be getting the boot.
And then all of a sudden there’s a bunch of witches everywhere.
Yeah, and all of a sudden it’s like on he has to save the community, you know? Oh my god be the hero. And so maybe by the time innocent people were being imprisoned and executed, the girls found themselves caught in a situation that had just spiraled and couldn’t take it back. There are some people who later on came forward and they were like, I did not lie, but I do feel bad about what happened. So that’s crazy. So what do you think?
You think I think it’s a mix of both. I think it’s a little bit of hysteria, but then mostly I think it’s like pettiness.
I still don’t understand. Like, why did you just let all these girls hang out together? I don’t understand. Like, again, all the documentaries, all the they’re like all just like sitting together uh in the pews, and then they’re like, it’s a witch, and they all start freaking out. I’m like, again, why didn’t we just say like what if we don’t believe the 10-year-old? Yes, yeah. What if we don’t have like this mob mentality? What if we separate you and keep you in your home and we individually talk to you, and then suddenly we realize that your stories are not matching at all, right? You’re a witch. We will see you next Tuesday. See you next Tuesday.