Hey, it’s Colleen. Hi, it’s Kate. And it’s Megan. And we’re the three scheme queens. We’re using our medical background to focus on the strange, baffling, and downright unsettling world of medical mysteries.
We’re gonna dig into unusual cases, diagnostic puzzles, unexplained symptoms, and medical misadventures.
Our first three seasons covered a little bit of everything, including crime, conspiracy, mystery, and the occasional rabbit hole we probably shouldn’t have gone down.
Those episodes aren’t going anywhere, so the archives remain open for anyone who likes their mysteries, a little more broad spectrum.
But from season four on, the prescription is different. More medicine, more mysteries, more questions. So grab a drink, hit the follow, and tune in every Tuesday for a new episode.
Hey guys, welcome back. How’s everything going? It’s this fall weather here, Megan. Except it actually is fridge and I’m like bundled up in blankets in Kate’s house. And I said, I might need to borrow a vest later. And I said, Oh. This is vest weather. It is vest weather. It might be colder than this weather tonight.
We’re gonna go to a high school football game. My daughter is gonna be performing at halftime, which is really fun. This is take two. We’re not supposed to talk about the weather, but that’s a lot of weather talk. Yeah. The first time it was rained out, so and then my son was like, Mom, it’s supposed to rain again on Friday. I was like, I can’t do this again.
Of course, Patch is like locked it on the weather too, though. He loves the weather. I believe that. Yeah. Like me. Remember when I wanted to be a meteorologist when I was a kid? I think you wanted to be a lot of things. Well, I did want to be on the news, but like not the news, you know. I wanted to be a meteorologist or a sports like reporter. Yeah, you want to be Aaron Andrews. Yeah. She was kind of big in our yeah. For our age, our era. Yeah. So I think I really missed my calling. Yeah. I just said to Kate, what if we go 50% in our healthcare jobs and then we just find something else to supplement the income? And she looked at me and she was like, Yeah, but but what is that? I was like, I know. When when we figure it out, we’ll let you know. Speaking of supplemented income, we have two new Patreon subscribers to the exam room, the upper tier. Amanda and Amber. Oh. So thank you for subscribing. You know, we’ve got some re-edited old school collections on there. Yep. We’re doing some, you get some early releases over there. Yep. And we’re doing some console queens over there. So yeah, if you just love us, actually, right now we’re on doubles Tuesday, Thursday, right? If that is still not enough for you, check us out on Patreon. Yeah. Let’s also shout out uh Tabitha and Ultra Neek, who are subscribers to our waiting room. New subscribers to our uh Patreon waiting room. So thanks, guys. And as always, guys, don’t forget to scroll on down, leave a five-star review, share the pod with a friend.
Yeah.
A friend, a family member, and an enemy, maybe? I don’t know. Yeah, we love an enemy. Yeah. A friend of me, if you will. So is it time for our drink chat?
Drink chat. Megan, can I tell you what I have been literally craving? A cookie butter latte, and that’s what I’m drinking right now.
Yeah, and I think we actually had this. It was not our drink check last time, but as we were finishing our apple cider prosecco cocktails, Bourbon Boy came in and passed out the coffee that he had gone on a run for. Yeah. And he had gotten us some. But those were iced cookie butter lattes. Well, you guys had a I never get iced latte. I don’t like iced stuff. I like it iced when it’s hot, but today, today it was too cold. I don’t think uh coffee tastes good iced.
I guess that’s just like hot take. Everyone likes an iced coffee these days, and I’m just like, I want a hot coffee with just a little bit of oat milk in it. Anyway, but this one is delicious.
It’s all the rage for myself these days. I am having a sugar cookie almond milk latte. And I swear last year they saw they weren’t making these at Starbucks. No, they weren’t. I don’t think so. So that’s what I’m having. Delicious.
Yeah.
I’m also intrigued. I’m like simultaneously intrigued and disgusted by the idea of the new Tiramisu latte. Why would you be disgusted about that? I mean, I had a pumpkin spice latte in the fall and I had two sips, and I was like, sugar coma. Okay. Pumpkin spice lattes are disgusting. I’ve never felt that way until this year. And then I went to pour it out because I was like, I can’t even drink this. It is straight sugar. I think I usually do like quite an adaptation, you know, like I do a lot of customization. Yeah. So I this time I just got one and I was like, it is way too sweet. Yeah. Got one. I went to dump out my pumpkin spice latte. And the artificial orange color that came out of that cup. Yeah. I I think somebody like looked at the pumpkin spice syrup for Starbucks at some point, and they were like, it the ingredients like did not list pumpkin. But the tiramisu, I’m intrigued by. And I’m like, well, it can’t be that. I mean, tyramisou is just like chocolate and cream and coffee. Right. So it can’t be that different. We don’t count calories here, okay? But it is a 500-calorie drink, which makes me think it might just be straight sugar. Right.
I just can’t see how it can be that different tasting than like the sweet cream cold brew. I always ask for less syrup. I always ask for one pump instead of because they put like four in.
Yeah, yeah. Do you know what else I did today?
Slept on the floor. She didn’t do that. Because this is what happened. She came, she drove me home from work because what a friend she is. I had a rough night. She, it’s all my people, you guys know. And I was like, I’m just gonna sleep at your house because Megan lives closer to the hospital than I do. And she said, you know what, do you want me to just drive you home? So we did. She drove me home, and then I slept on the couch. Then all of a sudden, I like was woken up to this like alarm going off, and I was like, all like disoriented, and Megan was on the ground sleeping next to me.
Yes, I drove her over because this girl is a real champ, okay? She worked a 24-hour shift, she saved multiple lives last night, and she’s like, We’re gonna record today. But I was trying to just let her have a leisurely day.
Yeah.
My alarm went off. I went, I got us the coffee, and came back, and I was like, now she’s got bread in the oven for so what a girl. We gotta do it. So before we came over, though, I did have to get Kate’s consult on some of my plants that are out of control. We need we’re gonna have to do a uh a little Lowe’s trip and get make some support. How are my two fiddle leaf figs looking this morning? Gosh, they are deriving. They look so good. There’s so many new leaves on them. The scariest thing I’ve ever done with my plants was follow the advice of Happy Happy Houseplant. And I they were looking tall and scrawtty, and I chopped them and I propped the chop and I did all of this like in the spring. Yeah. Put the plants outside for the summer. Yep. And they have gone out of control. They look so good. So good. So big fans of Happy Happy Houseplant. And they have been really kind to us. And they have a promo code for you all. So the links on our Instagram if you’re interested in trying out their plant food, or you can go to their website at happyhappyhouseplant.com and use coupon code three scheme queens. That’s the number three scheme queens, all one word, and get 10% off, and we get a little kickback. Yeah, it’s honestly like very much recommend.
And when we talk about the little plant food, it’s like fertilizer that you can give your plant and kind of it it nourishes them, it gives them a little vitamin, a little mineral, just things to keep the plant healthy and thriving. And I use it all the time. In fact, Megan gifted it to me like years ago. And now I’m just saying paying customer.
You’re a believer. I am a believer. They have other things too, besides just the plant food, but I swear by their plant food. Plant food is so good. And Mandy, oh my gosh, I she has such great tips. Such great tips for plant care. I know. I yeah, follow, follow them on Instagram also if you don’t. Okay. That being said, shall we get into it? Yes.
Disclaimer: the views, opinions, and commentary expressed on this podcast are those of the hosts and guests, and do not represent the view or opinions of our employers, organizations, or professional affiliations.
So today we’re doing a little uh true crime. I love that. True crime. True crime. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Love a medical mystery. Yes. And I think you are gonna have some really good thoughts for us about this. Okay. When Stacy Castor lost her first husband to an apparent heart attack and her second to an apparent suicide, she seemed like a woman plagued by unimaginable tragedy. But when investigators took a closer look, they uncovered a sinister connection between the depths. This week we’re diving into the chilling case of the woman dubbed the anti-freeze killer.
Oh.
We’re dissecting the medicine behind ethylene glycol poisoning, exploring how toxic metabolites can cause catastrophic organ failure, and examining the forensic evidence that helped investigators uncover a suspected pattern of murder. So let’s go back to August 22nd, 2005. 38-year-old Stacy Castor called 911 for a wellness check for her husband, David Castor. She claimed that he’d been on an alcohol binge and that they’d had like a big fight. He kicked her out of the bedroom, locked her out, and she had been staying with friends, but she worked at his business. They worked together. So now it’s Monday. He had failed to show up to work. He wasn’t answering her phone calls, so she calls the police. And when they entered the home, they discovered the master bedroom door was locked, as she said. They were forced to break down the door, and they discovered the dead body of David Castor. He was laying on a bare mattress and the room was covered in vomit and blood.
Ew.
Rigor Mortis had set in, and based on the scene, it was deemed a suicide. So things weren’t adding up. Right. Everyone’s like, this guy’s not suicidal. Okay. There’s an alarming amount of vomit. On the bedside table, they find apricot brandy, which is disgusting.
Yeah.
An empty jug of cranberry juice and two glasses, one of which contained a neon green liquid.
Neon green.
I mean, it’s somebody at a neon green liquid, I would be like, is this was this being used for crafting? Somebody using this for like sure you’d walk into the room with a naked man. I don’t mean to laugh, this is serious. Okay. I’m not sure you’d walk into the room with a naked man, vomit everywhere, and you’d be like, I think he was doing craft.
Oh, yeah, no, you’re definitely right. Uh I you know what?
I’m this, I’m I’m not putting, I just thought, Neon Green, this is a weird, but if if I was walked into a room and this is the the scene? The scene, I’d be like, oh, that’s poison. Okay. In my brain, I would say, oh, that’s definitely poison. I don’t know what it is, but it is poison. Yeah. Well, the police discovered an empty antifreeze bottle like under the bed, uh-huh, as well as a loaded shotgun. Oh my goodness. So they said, okay, we see neon green liquid, we see this antifreeze. That’s probably what this is. Yeah. And they also found an empty ambient prescription bottle. So they say, we think he was suicidal. He took drugs, alcohol, and antifreeze, and he tried to kill himself. Yeah. Investigators search the rest of the house for a possible suicide note. And in the trash in the kitchen, they find a brand new turkey baster.
Hmm.
That’s weird, right? That’s that is weird. They bag it and tag it and enter it as evidence.
Interesting that they were like, let’s bag and tag this turkey turkey.
Turkey. Did it have anything in it? Well, when it got tested, it did. Oh, okay. So, but it was like they were just like, that’s really weird. Why’d you throw away a brand new turkey baster? Yeah. Stacey’s the only one who’s like, I think he was suicidal, because she said he was despondent over the loss of his father, and they had had a fight, she said, going into the weekend because he wanted to take her on a romantic getaway, but she wanted her two daughters to come with. Uh-huh. And this is what prompted this big fight where he went to his room and locked her out and kicked her out. At one point during this weekend, he had passed out in his bathroom and Stacy had called a friend’s husband to come get him into bed. And we have proof-proof of this. Someone, someone alibied this. Like, yeah, I came over. He was drunk. I helped him get into bed. And the friend’s husband was like, I had never I had never seen him like that. He was too bad of it. Yeah. Well, why would you leave your somebody like that? If you’ve never seen anyone. Well, I mean, maybe he thought she’s like, he’s drunk. Can you help him? And then he’s probably like, I don’t want to be in the middle of this marital dispute. And his wife is his wife’s here. That that’s true. That’s true, I guess. I just, but I thought she had left for the weekend. Well, for part of the weekend, she was like sleeping on the couch. Oh, okay. At some point she went to a friend’s house. If you called me and you said, Megan, can you come help me with Bourbon Boy? And I’d be like, whoa, bourbon boy definitely went overboard. He’s gonna be hurting. And then I would help you with him, and then I’d be like, Looks like you got this. That’s kind of weird though, to like call a neighbor to help you with your spouse’s husband while you’re in the house.
I was thinking she’s out of the house and somebody came over to help him while he was inebriated.
And I like I wouldn’t leave that person. I think she was there and she summoned help because he’s a big dude. Anyway, the the cause of death is that this 48-year-old man died of ethylene glycol poisoning. That is what the autopsy reveals. Okay. Okay. And this matched up with the opinion of the police who said, yep, we saw the ethylene glycol, which is anti-freeze, in the cup. We saw the empty container. We thought suicide checks out. So let’s pause our story there and let’s talk about ethylene glycol. Okay. So it’s a major ingredient of almost all radiator fluid products in the United States. It is used to increase the boiling point and decrease the freezing point of fluid that circulates through the radiator to prevent your radiator from overheating in the summer and freezing in the winter. Oh, interesting. So it’s like salt in water.
You know, when you add salt to water, it increases the boiling point and it decreases the freezing point. So you never add your your salt before you boil the pasta because it increases your boiling time for your pasta. Thank you for that chemistry lesson? Yeah.
Now, the danger with ethylene glycol is not so much the chemical itself, but what happens when the body tries to break it down. Yeah. When someone swallows antifreeze, the liver uses an enzyme called alcohol dehydrogenase to process it. So when you ingest it, uh-huh, it’s rapidly absorbed within one to four hours. And so the unmetabolized compound, it acts very much like when you consume ethanol. Right. You get this same kind of symptom. So like CNS depression, intoxication, and you get a hyperosmolarity, uh-huh, which then would maybe cause a little acidosis. Right. So hyperosmolarity is just when you have a high concentration of solutes as compared to water, right? Dehydration, if you will, like we get when we drink alcohol. Yep. You also get this acidosis because when we look at our our hydrogen ions. Yes, we have our positive and negative ions. Yep. And for most of us who are walking around healthy, those balance each other out. Yes. So like chloride is negative, sodium is positive, sodium is positive, tacitism is positive, bicarb is negative, high carb is negative. So those are the big ones we talk about. There’s a lot more involved in that. Yes. And so some of them live inside the cell, some of them live outside the cell.
And sometimes if you have a cell that’s like spilling positive ions, then you have like what what we call is an acidosis.
Yep. And we just say like the pH of our blood, right, should really be around 7.4. And if it gets different things can make it more more alkalotic or more acidotic. But yes, when you get acidotic, then then uh cause a number of issues we’ll talk about. And also, you know, we medications don’t work as well because that’s not that’s not like the ideal environment for these meds to work. Yes. That’s kind of what happens in the first couple of hours is you sort of get drunk, a little dehydrated, start to develop this acidosis related to the electrolyte abnormalities. Okay. But as I said, the real danger comes when the ethylene glycol is broken down by the body. So as I mentioned, the liver uses the enzyme alcohol dehydrogenase to process it, which is exactly how we break down ethanol as well. Yep. But unfortunately, unlike ethanol, when we break down the ethylene glycol, it turns into a highly toxic substance. And then this causes more metabolites to build up in the blood. So again, it makes more of an acidosis. Uh-huh. And then what is what do our bodies do to try to compensate for that? We breathe faster. Yep. Yep. We hyperventilate to to blow off COVID. Yes.
Two different ways that you can compensate in the body. You compensate in your with your lungs or you compensate with your kidneys. And in this case, you would develop a an acidosis that your body would compensate with your lungs.
Yes. And so these patients start to kind of hyperventilate. Yes. From hours 12 to 48, the acidosis continues to worsen, but this is primarily the result of an increase in glycolic acid, although glyoxalic, oxalic, and lactic acids also contribute. Oh. If we talk about the glycolysis and lactic acidosis, the liver cells are flooded with NADH, uh nicotinamide, adenine dinucleotide. Okay. Does that sound right? Which is the native energy carrying form of what coenzyme? B3. Niacin. Yeah. Yes. It forces pyruvate to convert into lactate instead of entering normal aerobic energy. Lactate. Okay, this is explaining to a patient overnight. Yes. Yeah. Uh embarrassing moment because why did I have to get into the into the cellular level?
They literally said, What is lactic acidosis? And I said, Oh, I’m so happy you asked. And then I started talking about anaerobic metabolism. And they just silence, silence. And I was like, and then a nurse was on the phone with me, and she goes, It’s, you know what? Your dad’s really sick.
It’s like a perfusion issue. So so yes, when we go, when our body doesn’t have enough oxygen to fuel it, we go into this anaerobic metabolism and you get lactate that builds. Which is like amazing. Our body tries to compensate as much as we can.
You know, this our normal body, our body performs normally with oxygen. But then when we don’t have oxygen, it still needs to perform all the duties that it needs to do. And so there’s this sort of secondary mechanism that your body will go into called anaerobic metabolism, so that you can still produce this energy that your body needs to kind of function. And this happens like on a like a normal basis. Like you can go um work out at the gym and you are your body is under an anaerobic sort of condition. And that’s when you, you know, you have the lactic buildup in your muscles. Like that’s literally what’s happening in your muscles when you go to the gym and you have the soreness. That’s kind of like what’s happening when a patient is sick. But it’s just different mechanisms in which it is being done.
Well said. Yeah. Because the high NADH levels pull pyruvate toward lactate, liver knot can cannot easily convert the pyruvate back into glucose. So we have an issue with like our our gluconeogenesis that just kind of messes with the whole cycle. The whole Krebs cycle, yes. And we also know when the liver’s stress, you can’t clear your lactate. Yeah. So lactose up as well. Yes. As your astidosis gets bad, it leads to cardiovascular collapse, reduced oxygen-deliberated tissues. It’s sort of like a catch-22. Like we have this lactic acidosis, but then we have to rely on the anaerobic glycolysis, and so it causes more lactic acidosis. And so you’re gonna get worse. And you’re again, your our body is not meant to function at pHs that low. The other metabolic waste product I was I mentioned is oxalate. So your liver also naturally produces oxalate and it is a normal metabolic waste product. But when you take antifreeze, it puts it in overdrive, produces a surplus of oxalate. So you get too much oxalate, which is a negative ion. And so what does that want to bind with? A positive. That’s right. And what is positive? If we have a neg an oxalate, we have a negative two. What’s what’s got a positive two? Calcium. So again, when it binds to calcium, calcium oxalate is not water soluble. So you told us a couple weeks ago. What does that mean? It it can’t dissolve in water. Yeah, so it’s gonna hang around. Yeah. Right? So does it create a solution, like a salt? It causes tiny sharp crystals to accumulate all over the body. Yeah. But like in all the organs. Uh-huh. But the real issue in these patients is that they uh accumulate in the kidneys. Oh, they cause obstruction, inflammation of the tubules, and eventual renal failure. Yeah. And as you mentioned, how do we clear acid usually? Our kidneys are our lungs. So if now our kidneys aren’t working, the acid is building up. And it’s getting worse because yes, it’s just getting worse and worse and worse. This is horrible. The calcium binding decreases calcium circul circulating calcium at the same time. Yeah. So we are now we have this like um Cardiovascular collapse. Claudiovascular cardiovascular collapse from the acidosis, but on top of that, we have loss of calcium. And what does calcium do? Helps our heart beat. Yeah, stabilizes the heart. Yeah. So now we’re having more issues uh leading to spasms, seizures, arrhythmia, and death. Yep. Okay. So that is my quick and dirty about I think you did a good job. Ethylene glycol. Yeah. It sounds like a horrible thing that anyone would have. It doesn’t sound like you can. Is there anything that binds to it? I’m so happy you asked. I was gonna tell you later, Robin, tell it now. Okay. Okay. I’m so happy you asked. So interestingly, regular drinking alcohol ethanol competes for the same liver enzyme. So they used to just give these people ETOH. Oh. Because they’re like, if you can slow it down, if you can make give the liver more time to process this and to clear the metabolites, then you’re gonna be fine. But if it’s just so overwhelmed, that’s the problem. Right. Okay. So they would give patients ethanol to like to compete. So it would just give the body more time to to clear the toxic body. Then at some sometime, at some point you’re gonna like pee it out or poop it out.
Cause sometimes at some point you’re like, you’ve got to excrete.
Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I mean, it’s just like regular alcohol. Yeah. Now the this ethanol is kind of old school and it’s largely been replaced by fometizole. Fomepazole works by blocking alcohol dehydrogenase, which I told you is the uh enzyme use. So it’s it competes again, right? So it essentially stops the liver from turning ethylene glycol into its toxic metabolites, giving the body more time to eliminate the antifreeze before it causes serious damage. So that’s usually the big treatment, but you have to get there soon enough to like have already, you know, get there early. Yeah. And you can give some phemepazole. And then in severe cases, you may need dialysis because, again, when your kidneys fail, that’s how we remove the acids from the body, right? Pyroxidine and thiamine are cofactors in ethylene glycol metabolism that promote the production of non-toxin metabolites. So sometimes these are used as like adjuncts, but the literature told me that there’s actually no benefit to um pyrodoxine and thiamine.
So it’s probably like you throw in the throw in the boat, like the kitchen sink of these to try and get them to stay with. Anything. Yeah.
Back to our case, as I mentioned, was that this was suicide by ingestion of ambient and ethylene glycol. But again, people are like, I just we just told you about this like several day long painful process. Right. And so people are like, he wasn’t suicidal. And if he was gonna kill himself, there was a shotgun there. Right. Why would he go do this like painful death? Why would he just like vomit and blood all over the house? Yes, continue to vomit and all when you could just end it. Yeah. Especially if that was the end game. And then some of the friends and family were like, I’m actually concerned about Stacy and David’s relationship. David’s ex-wife came out and was like, I promise you, David would not have killed himself. Yeah. Police decided to continue to investigate and they discovered a few more oddities. They found out Stacy had been having an affair, which okay, doesn’t make her guilty, but that’s not good luck. Step one. Step one. Yeah. We have a motive, maybe. Yeah, right. The forensic evidence showed that turkey baster. Uh-huh. You asked what was in it. Yeah. It had David’s DNA and remnants of antifreeze. The theory is that she that maybe someone was forcing him to consume this antifreeze.
Oh my gosh, like when he was asleep, or like when he was did she make him get drunk and then like put it down his throat? That sounds like cute.
She he was she was baby birding him. Maybe. Yeah. Yeah. Not quite baby birding if it doesn’t go in her mouth first.
Well, he it’s she’s depositing it in his mouth.
Okay. Stacy’s fingerprints were all over the booze, the that apricot liquor. Yeah, that’s disgusting. And the anti-free gr anti-freeze glasses, but David’s were not. Quick question.
Do we think she went to the grocer like to like a gas station and she was like, give me your cheapest liquor? And the guy behind the counter was like apricot.
You know what? We don’t yuck on anyone’s yum. Okay, well Apricot. It’s brandy or sherry. And then I told you that she was like, I have been hammer calling my husband who didn’t come to work, and he’s not answering. Cell phone records say that was a lie. She called one time and that was it. And then what got most interesting to the police was that this was not Stacy’s first dead husband. So so she had a first husband who died. She has a plot. He’s buried. There’s a headstone with her name on it, uh-huh. That she’s gonna be buried next to him. Uh-huh. And then she takes this new husband the sec the second dead husband, buries him right next to her. So can you imagine also being like, this bee murdered me? Yeah. And now I have to spend eternity buried next to her and her first husband, who she also probably killed. Yeah. Awful. Her first husband was Michael Wallace. She had met when she him when she was 17. She was a senior in high school. He was older. I think he was like 24 or something. She ended up pregnant with her first daughter, Ashley, who was born in 1987. He left her because he was like, I’m not, I don’t want to be a dad. But they eventually reconciled. They got married, and in 1991, they had their second daughter, Brie. She started having an affair in that first marriage. Uh-huh. And a decade into that marriage, he became ill, complaining of lightheadedness and gait issues. Oh. He actually went to the to the doctor and said, I feel like I’m drunk, but I’m not drunk. Yeah. Okay. Which sounds suspicious. Suspicious. The symptoms got progressively worse until he died. He like died on his couch and his daughter was there. But she thought he was sick and just went to sleep. Oh my God. She went to like get her sister and came back and realized she was like, I think he died in front of me, and I had no idea. Oh my God. That is so disturbing. It gets worse for her, though. So my gosh. So then they were like, you know what else is weird? Is that this guy he was 38, he died. He was sick. He died. They took him to the hospital. And the doctor said, We think he had a heart attack. Stacy says, Good enough for me. We’re done. And does it get an autopsy? Oh my gosh. And there’s a lot of talk about that. And I kind of have mixed feelings. I do think that he unexpectedly died. And I think when you call, when you call your medical examiner after a patient dies and you go through the checklist, that does meet criteria. Right. So she shouldn’t have really gotten a say in it. No. Like it meets criteria for an autopsy because it’s suspicious. Right. Now, if it didn’t meet criteria, I don’t think it’s that crazy for her not to get an autopsy because if it’ll be criteria, you gotta pay for that. And that’s thousands of dollars. Right. So everyone being like, that’s so suspicious that she didn’t get an autopsy. I think it’s weird he didn’t get one, but I don’t think that’s on her. Right. But I would say that I feel like if your husband dropped dead at 38, you would be like 100%. This is weird. Yes. Please tell me more. Yes. An otherwise healthy male.
Yes. Complaining of being sick, but not able to.
And I feel like you’d be like, and also we have two daughters. So if there’s something we need to know about, yeah, well. They ended up exhuming her first husband’s body. The police on this one. Exuming. Okay. They’re like, this is weird. This is he’s buried right next to the other one. Yeah. Let’s just dig him on up. Oh, my wait, the first husband. So I said the second husband died. Yeah. And then I tried to do a big reveal. We’re like, then they went back and found out that the first husband had also died mysteriously. Yeah. So they exhumed the body and they discovered crystals consistent with antifreeze poisoning. Those crystals, the calcium oxalate I told you. But here’s my other question. How dumb did she have to be? To do it twice? To not cremate this person. Oh. She got away with it. She didn’t eat it. Cremate them. The first one allegedly died of a heart attack. Second one allegedly died of suicide. Okay. Second one was found naked. And as we talked about in our Marilyn Monroe episode, people who commit suicide almost never commit suicide naked. No. No one wants to be found that way. No. So that’s very uncommon. Yeah. They also said that women, like poisoning is a very female suicide. Yes. And men are more likely to like shoot themselves. Yeah. Like a little bit more. Well, they’re, you know, women, it’s like what they say is women really don’t want to kill themselves because it’s a cry for attention. That’s what they say. Right. Okay. And that men just make the decision and do it. We already have listeners who think we’re not mentally help-friendly. How I would interpret that is that I’m thinking I if I I don’t want to kill myself. But you know, have we ever not ever thought ways we don’t want to go? Right? We’ve all thought about that. Yeah. And calming. I feel like probably not anti-freeze. I would disagree with this way of going. But like just going to sleep from some meds sounds like a much better way to go. I guess jumping out a window or shooting yourself. I just feel like it’s probably women are women think it through more because that’s what women do. Yeah. I guess when I think about poisoning, I don’t think of overdose. Okay. What do you think? Or like poisoning as far as like you’re not thinking like an ambient overdose is the same as poisoning. No.
I also agree. If I were gonna do it, I’d take a bunch of we want to be comfortable. We’re not gonna No plan.
Okay.
Uh me on SI.
So now police again are like, okay, there are all these inconsistencies. We have exhumed this body. We had we had an autopsy on the first on the second husband. It was definitely ethylene glycol. We now have exhumed this other body. We know that he also had ethylene glycol in his system when he died. What are the odds that both of these husbands would die with ethylene glycol in their system? This isn’t even the most ridiculous. Like the story’s not even done yet, okay? Yeah. So in the meantime, they also find out that around the time her first husband died, yeah, her father also died. Oh he was in the hospital. He had been feeling lousy, went to the hospital. He seemed to be doing better in the hospital. She brought him a soda, visited him, he promptly took a turn for the worse and died. Wait, this lady, what is her problem? Oh no. Also, like, what’s what’s she got $55,000 from the first husband? I’m like, did she get any money from the dad? Like, what is the motivation with the dad here? Right. What does she have against the men in her life? And she’s so now we’re now we’re at maybe three murders and we’re not even done yet. Oh. In September, they are surveilling Stacy. I guess they’d already read her for questioning. They already had like, she didn’t want to talk. Yeah. They said something like, Which glass did you touch? And she said, Well, when I pulled the anti-free, I mean the cranberry juice. So she practically admitted it to the police. Yes. Then she panicked and she said, You know what? I don’t want to talk to you more. I don’t want to talk to you anymore. And the cop in 2020, on the 2020 session’s like, So I I go, Okay, you lawyered up. And so he picks up all of his documents and puts them in a pile. Uh-huh. And in that pile is a photo of the Neon Green. No, of the turkey baster. Oh, yeah. And so she goes, What’s the turn? Why do you have a picture of that? And he says, You don’t want to talk. We’re not talking. Yeah. So she knows now that it’s fallen apart. Yeah. Okay. So they’re surveilling her. They’ve wiretapped her. Uh-huh. And she has a daughter. Her daughter, Ashley, is like in college. She’s about 20. She’s like, let’s get drunk tonight. Her and her daughter. So they like have a drink, whatever. Like a week goes by, and she again she calls around. She’s like, let’s do it again. Let’s go big. So her and her daughter have a little rager. Uh-huh. Just the two of them. Although it sounds like not much of a rager. It sounds like less than a drink was consumed. But they’re boozing up. Stacy brings her daughter, Ashley, a drink. Uh-huh. Ashley goes, This tastes weird. She took it back into the kitchen. She like remixed it, diluted a little bit. There’s also a story that she was like, just drink it with a straw. Yeah. And she kind of like encouraged her to drink this drink. And she goes, I remember nothing after that. The next morning, Ashley’s sister, Brie, finds her unwell in her bed. Oh my gosh. And Brie’s like, Mom, we have to call the police. So September 14th, Stacy calls 911 to let them know that she’s found her daughter Ashley and she thinks she overdosed. EMS arrives, they find her unconscious but alive. And as they load her up to take her to the hospital, Stacy hands them a suicide note. Everyone’s like, why does she care? Why would she be so focused on this like suicide note? You’d be focused on like helping your daughter, right? Right. She wanted everyone to know that there was a suicide note. Yeah. The suicide note is a confession where Ashley claims that she poisoned her dad and then later her stepdad with antifreeze. Toxicology screen comes back positive for barbiturates, alcohol, opioids, specifically oxycodone. But when she she’s like, I remember having drink with my mom, and then I remember waking up at the hospital surrounded by police. Yeah. And they’re yelling at me, what did you take? What did you take? Did you try to kill yourself? Okay. Yeah. They’re like, Well, did you try to keep we have this note? And she says, I did not write that note. I remember nothing, but I know I did not write that note. Yeah. The other interesting thing about the note is that remember I told you Stacy said, Well, when I went to pour the anti-free, I mean the cranberry juice. Yeah. Apparently, anti-free is like a phrase only she used. Because it’s anti-freeze, right? Yeah. Yeah. In the con in the confession, in the suicide note, yeah, she talks about, you know, this alleged Ashley talks about killing her stepdad with anti-free. And they’re like, you know where we’ve heard that term before? From your mother. Yeah. Right? So Stacy ended up getting arrested for the murder of her second husband, the one we started talking about, who allegedly uh committed suicide. This this lady is so dumb. So while she’s in custody under arrest for the murder of her second husband, they are also bouncing a case against her for attempted murder on her daughter. Yeah. They were able to search the home and they found drafts of the suicide note on Stacy’s computer. Of course. And Ashley was awake, like they actually, because they had been tapping her and they went back and they listened to the audio and they figured out that at one point Ashley was at school. Stacy was talking to her on the phone. And while they were talking, Stacy was typing this fake suicide note to frame her daughter for double murder. Oh my gosh. And suicide. This lady is. Did did she ever like say what her motive was? Like she maintained that she did not do this. Oh my gosh. She continues to blame her daughter, Ashley. And her mom, this is the saddest part, is her mom was on 2020, this little old lady with white hair. And she also was like, I don’t believe my daughter did it. I think it was Ashley. What? In February 2009, Ashley do it to herself. Why would she take all these drugs and do it to then do that? I don’t know. She was tormented by what she had done, allegedly, but in February 2009, Stacy Castor is convicted of second-degree murder of David Castor and attempted second-degree murder of Ashley Wallace. That’s her daughter. David’s wife, her current husband who died of suicide, allegedly. I told you his ex-wife had been like, he didn’t do it. He also had a son with his ex-wife. Apparently, David’s will had been changed days before his death and left everything to Stacy. And this guy had like not a lot of money, but he had a lot of toys. He had a lot of like assets. He owned his own business. He had owned his own air conditioning business, but he had, they said he had like cars and snowmobiles and like boat, a boat, and jet ski. Yeah. And he left nothing to his son, who he was like on good terms with. Yeah. Everything to his wife. And again, this all was like days before his death. They had a handwriting expert who deemed that the signature was not David’s. Uh-huh. So she was also charged and found guilty of fraud. Yeah. So jail for the murder, attempted murder, and fraud. She was eligible for parole in 51 years. So at 2050 in 2055, at the age of 88, she would have been eligible, eligible for parole, but she ended up dying in her cell. She was found dead June 11th, 2016, and they did an autopsy and it was an MI, and it said all natural causes, and she died at the age of 48. She didn’t die of Andy Free. No, I so she was never convicted of the death of her first husband. She was never tried for that. Yeah. Michael Wallace, her first husband, they did go back and change his cause of death to homicide, but Stacy was never separately convicted of that murder. So we all assume she’s died now. She’s not going to face any charges for that. But the the assumption is that she killed her first husband, killed her second husband, maybe killed her dad, and tried to kill her daughter. I can’t believe the grandmother was like, Yeah, it’s the my granddaughter.
She did it.
Yeah. Well, it’s gonna be hard. Very hard. Five years ago. So her daughter, what was she like 20? So it was five years. Okay, she was 15. She killed her her dad at 15. Yeah, no. Alright, that’s all I have. Any other thoughts?
I don’t think 15-year-olds have enough of like like precognition. I don’t know. Like to poison. 15-year-olds are gonna be like, I guess let me, you know, stab or shoot or something.
Not you think. Like I feel like Antifreeze feels very specific. And and like, how did she know that like, okay, it’s sweet and it’s and it’s it can be easily concealed in a cocktail and people are they’re just he’s just gonna look drunk, and I can call his fr I can call a friend over to help me so they can observe that he is drunk and it will like confirm my story of this alcohol binge. Right. I mean, I knew that ethylene glycol caused an acidosis, and I know what goes along with that, but actually reading about like the crystals deposited in all of your organs and this taking three days to work, like to to lead to death feels like a terrible way to go. It really does. It’s not a way I would I would not suggest anybody ever drink ethylene glycol.
No. Okay. Um, have you heard of when people like drink Draino?
Oh, but do you know what it does? It sounds awful. What? It just erodes your esophagus. Well, I’m sure because it erodes. Oh, and then they died of like an esophageal perforation type situation. Isn’t that awful? That’s not a way to go either. No, it’s it’s incredibly painful and there’s like no way to stop it. It once you do it, you’re done.
Done. And even if they’re like they drink it and then they go to the ER and they’re like, I just did something horrible.
Like, no, that’s it. Well, that’s also the things like like if anyone feels depressed, you should certainly reach out for help. Okay. Yeah. We want to suicide hop signs. Yeah. We don’t, we are not like, but in general trying to give anyone advice. But in general, I think a lot of these poisoning things that people do, like, they’re not instantaneous. No. I think like it’s like the ty right always learnt about like the Tylenol. When you overdose on Tylenol, that it’s gonna take a while and it’s like you know it’s coming, but like I guess that’s what I mean when I say like when you say women do poisoning, to me that means there’s more time to change their mind. Like they’re not connected to it. Yeah, but no, but I think a lot of these they do it. So it’s like again, I think with Tylenol and with like we were describing like an esophageal perforation, yeah. Like you know that it’s done and you know it’s irreversible, right? And now we’re going to just have to wait for three days while you slowly get worse and worse and worse. Well, Tylenol’s not done immediately. You can intervene on a liver transplant. Can’t you give like NAD or something? Yeah, but I don’t know if that really I think if you catch Tylenol overdose fast enough. Within eight hours, you can reverse.
You can take the antibiotics or antibiotics. You can take the Tylenol and then be like, I immediately regret that and go, but not a lot of people do that. You gotta be immediately take it and then they wait, and then they and then they don’t go oh no, I don’t want to do this, and then it’s probably longer than eight hours, and you know, then you’re like, well, you’re kidding, you’re sure you’re just done.
Yeah. All right, well, that’s all we have. So yeah, come back next week and we’re gonna do um console queens. Yeah. Kate’s favorite segment. It’s it is my favorite segment. And is it gonna be, yeah, I think we’re gonna do Grays Anatomy. It’s gonna be Kate’s first ever pop the cherry. All right, sounds good. We will see you next Tuesday. See you next Tuesday.
