In this minisode, we investigate the conspiracy theory that the cookies sold at Dollar Tree are essentially Girl Scout cookies, just sold under a different brand and at a fraction of the price. We’re digging into the companies behind Girl Scout cookies, the surprisingly similar cookies that show up on dollar-store shelves, and why some people swear that their favorite Girl Scout flavors have a suspiciously affordable doppelgänger.

Is this a legitimate cookie-industry connection, a brilliant Girl Scout marketing strategy, or simply a case of two cookies being really freaking similar? We follow the crumbs, compare the evidence, and decide whether this conspiracy deserves a Thin Mint-sized dose of skepticism, or a trip to Dollar Tree. Because if you can get your peanut butter cookie fix for $1.25 instead of $6… we have questions.